2. Big Red (Western Kentucky)
The Hilltoppers in their defense are in a tough spot. It has to be extremely difficult to try to produce a creative-looking mascot costume when your nickname is the Hilltoppers. Nonetheless, we have to call it what it is.
Big Red basically looks like a giant red blob on the field and is not aesthetically appealing whatsoever, putting him near the top of the list for worst college mascot for many fans.